No Kill Huntsville
  • Home
  • Shelter Issues
    • Our Animal Shelter
    • Shelter Statistics - 2023 >
      • 2022
      • 2020-2021
      • 2019
      • 2018
      • 2017
      • 2016
      • 2015
      • 2008-2014
  • No Kill Concepts
    • Pet Overpopulation
    • Dispelling Myths
    • The No Kill Equation
    • No Kill Materials
    • For Rescuers
  • How You Can Help
    • Express Yourself
    • Local Officials
  • Helpful Links
  • About Us
    • Our Vision
    • In the Media
  • Contact Us
  • Blog
  • Community Resources
  • The HAPA

Transparency and the Public Trust

3/15/2016

0 Comments

 
We have a page on our website where we post shelter statistics. They go back to 2008. The most recent statistics we have on the site are the monthly figures for December of 2015. We were asked yesterday why we don't have the year end numbers for 2015 and the monthly numbers for January and February of this year. We don't have them posted because the city has not provided them to us.

In Alabama, records related to the operation of the government are public records which can be sought by any person and for any reason under the Alabama Open Records Act. There are some exceptions to the Act, but it is pretty broad in terms of access and the records can be sought by anyone, whether they live in Alabama or not. When it comes to Madison County, seeking animal control records is a pretty simple process. We call or email the Animal Control Director and he provides the records, normally within a matter of minutes or hours. When it comes to the City of Huntsville, the process is not so simple. We have been given very clear instructions that we are not to communicate directly with the Animal Services Director and that our records requests must be submitted to the City Attorney's Office to be processed. This means that we prepare a letter  each month which we submit to the City Attorney's Office setting forth the records we seek.

We have been trying to get records regarding dogs destroyed in the last quarter of 2015 for months. We have been trying to get the 2015 year-end statistics since January. Our last letter to the City Attorney's Office was sent on March 7, 2016.  We have considered speaking to an attorney for help in getting the records we seek. We have also considered getting the media involved. We have not yet decided what we plan to do about this issue. The records we seek don't have to be created. They already exist and it is a matter of printing them off of a computer or otherwise saving them as a .pdf file.

In spite of the opinions of those who oppose us for our advocacy, we have worked incredibly hard since our coalition formed to be both diplomatic and respectful in our communication with and criticism of the city and Huntsville Animal Services.  We have made a concerted effort to applaud progress made by the city even when we have been under attack on social media. In the fall of  last year, a "hate" page was created about our coalition on Facebook. We didn't talk about it publicly we didn't want to draw attention to it. It contained content which was juvenile, vulgar and libelous, much of which was "liked" and commented on by city employees, shelter volunteers and prominent members of local rescue organizations.  We took steps to try to have the page removed while refusing to stoop to the level of those who felt that type of behavior was appropriate or productive.  As they saying goes, we just would not "go there."

The city has made enough progress in the last year that there is little point in remaining overly critical and risk having people think we won't be satisfied with any level of progress. Although ours is not yet a no kill community, Huntsville has made a great amount of progress in a short amount of time and the value of that cannot be overstated. We remain hopeful the city will make a commitment to make ours a no kill community and declare that healthy and treatable animals are not at risk under any circumstances.

We believe that with increased progress and increased expectations by the city that the public will both be part of change and fully support change comes the need for complete transparency in record keeping. It is vital in order to both get and maintain the public trust. The ASPCAs Position Statement on Responsibilities of Animal Shelters speaks to this very point:

Goal 4:  Animal sheltering is increasingly transparent


The ASPCA strongly supports a requirement that key records and data be maintained by all shelters, both public and private, routinely reported to an appropriate central entity, and made available to the public. While much of this information, for public shelters at least, may already be considered a public record under various state laws, the ASPCA believes that standardizing the information that must be collected and extending these requirements to private shelters is not only an important step toward transparency, but also an effective way to gain a fuller picture of the community’s at-risk animals.  When the only information available concerning intake and outcomes is that which must be provided by public shelters through Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests, the public is receiving an incomplete and perhaps distorted representation of these matters.


There is a video on the city's Youtube channel which shows Mayor Battle interviewing Dr. Sheppard about the operation of Huntsville Animal Services and talking about the tremendous progress made at our shelter in recent months. At one point in the interview, Mayor Battle calls Dr. Sheppard a star. Although we have been quite complimentary of that progress, it is somewhat difficult for us to be quite as thrilled with the progress because of the city's lack of transparency regarding the shelter records.

Once we have been provided the records we seek, we will post them on our website. The City of Huntsville should have nothing to hide. And we look forward to seeing that with our own eyes very soon when we are provided the records we have sought not just for us but for our entire community.

Picture
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    No Kill Huntsville

    Keep up with our updates and latest news regarding Huntsville becoming a no kill community.

    Archives

    January 2022
    January 2020
    November 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    September 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    December 2016
    September 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015

    Categories

    All
    Accuracy
    Advocacy
    Animal Welfare
    Bad News
    CAPA
    Chipathon
    Commitment
    Communication
    Community Outreach
    Culture
    Dog Evaluations
    Education
    Euthanasia
    Fine Tuning
    Good News
    Healthy And Treatable
    History
    Legislation
    Lessons Learned
    Looking Forward
    Municipal Accountability
    No Kill
    No Kill Equation
    Open Records Act
    Opposition
    Personal Responsibility
    Proactive Redemptions
    Progress
    Public Safety
    Public Trust
    Reducing Intake
    Research
    Saving 90
    Shelter Reform
    Shelter Reports
    Spay And Neuter
    Struggle
    Transparency
    Words Matter
    Year In Review

    RSS Feed

    image courtesy of Terrah Johnson
Picture
Copyright © 2015
Picture
Photo used under Creative Commons from Brian Royal Roberts
  • Home
  • Shelter Issues
    • Our Animal Shelter
    • Shelter Statistics - 2023 >
      • 2022
      • 2020-2021
      • 2019
      • 2018
      • 2017
      • 2016
      • 2015
      • 2008-2014
  • No Kill Concepts
    • Pet Overpopulation
    • Dispelling Myths
    • The No Kill Equation
    • No Kill Materials
    • For Rescuers
  • How You Can Help
    • Express Yourself
    • Local Officials
  • Helpful Links
  • About Us
    • Our Vision
    • In the Media
  • Contact Us
  • Blog
  • Community Resources
  • The HAPA